QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:
You said he got to the SB,...got to the NFCCG. You didnt bring up any of these other positions when you claimed "Brock got there."

No one ever does when saying a QB got his team to a SB o4 Championship Game.

When the player has success: "LOOK AT WHAT HE DID!"

When the player doesn't: "LOOK AT HIS SUPPORTING CAST!"

"No one ever does" -- I dont really care what random posters do or don't do. Simply pointing out the clear fallacy,...which got you AND HIM in trouble with over-loving Jimmy.

Please...learn from your mistakes, lol.

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:
You said he got to the SB,...got to the NFCCG. You didnt bring up any of these other positions when you claimed "Brock got there."

No one ever does when saying a QB got his team to a SB o4 Championship Game.

When the player has success: "LOOK AT WHAT HE DID!"

When the player doesn't: "LOOK AT HIS SUPPORTING CAST!"

"No one ever does" -- I dont really care what random posters do or don't do. Simply pointing out the clear fallacy,...which got you AND HIM in trouble with over-loving Jimmy.

Please...learn from your mistakes, lol.

I mean if you're using that as a negotiating tactic, then the same can be said for ALL QB's, did you think Mahomes and Tom Brady won their Super Bowls by themselves?

Originally posted by mayo49:
Too, much for just a solid Qb, don't want just stock. Give me something that comes with a little extra.

What

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by mayo49:
Too, much for just a solid Qb, don't want just stock. Give me something that comes with a little extra.

What

Very reasonable response.

Originally posted by random49er:

When the player has success: "LOOK AT WHAT HE DID!"

When the player doesn't: "LOOK AT HIS SUPPORTING CAST!"

"No one ever does" -- I dont really care what random posters do or don't do. Simply pointing out the clear fallacy,...which got you AND HIM in trouble with over-loving Jimmy.

Please...learn from your mistakes, lol.

LOL at bringing up Jimmy. Whatever your point is, you lost.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by random49er:
When the player has success: "LOOK AT WHAT HE DID!"

When the player doesn't: "LOOK AT HIS SUPPORTING CAST!"

"No one ever does" -- I dont really care what random posters do or don't do. Simply pointing out the clear fallacy,...which got you AND HIM in trouble with over-loving Jimmy.

Please...learn from your mistakes, lol.

LOL at bringing up Jimmy. Whatever your point is, you lost.

I know it hurts.

Brock is going to be offered a pretty good amount of money. Exactly what it is remains to be seen.

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
LOL at bringing up Jimmy. Whatever your point is, you lost.

reality is with jimmy first off, we signed him big money and that was happening as soon as we did the trade. when he balled out in 2017 it was happening for sure. so we all got behind him as the deal was done right away and we always won with jimmy. that's just a reality. 2017 we won, 2019 we won, 2021 we won, 2022 when healthy we won, he was injured the other years. now you can say we won in spite of him or with the guys around him, whatever your argument may be. but he never started and had a losing season like this season.

Originally posted by random49er:
Brock is going to be offered a pretty good amount of money. Exactly what it is remains to be seen.

Believe me, Brock will be able to give his linemen Escalades not Toyota's, after he gets his next bag.

Originally posted by 49erKing:
Lately I've been drafting Wyatt Millum and Nate Ratledge, 1st and 3rd, in next year's draft for us. LT and G, both 6'6, 320 lbs.

I see Millum as an IOL at the next level?

Originally posted by TheWooLick:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Dude he's missing more reads/not seeing the field as well, his footwork and processing has taken a step back, which has lead to inaccuracies.

Absolutely the players around him have helped lead to success and hurt him this year.

his TT shows he's not seeing the field properly

Not enough ppl recognize "time to throw" as not just being quick game play calls, but the ability to recognize coverage weaknesses, eliminate options that don't have a chance & getting eyes on "read" defender quickly to simplify game & get ball out!

Maybe the most underrated… https://t.co/8EW0dYfHgb

— Kurt Warner (@kurt13warner) December 26, 2024

Folks are saying Brock just might need a better roster around him a little bit more than some of the other highly paid guys in the league. Why is that so far fetched?

He isn't as good as Mahomes. Does anyone disagree?

It's about TT and processing everything. Read what Warner said.

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:

Do with Brock what we did with Ayiuk. Find out if other teams are even interested and for how much. Bring in Cousins or Darnold as a backup plan if he holds out.

It's time we show Brock what a hardball actually is.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
See that's the thing, I've blamed Brock plenty during game day threads, I just don't dwell on it like some do in here. I also blame Shanahan for some of his play calling but lets face it injuries have played a big factor this season. Re-building the trenches next off season will be something to keep an eye on. I don't see Brendel starting next season and I don't see a rookie there either, my bet is Shanahan goes after another veteran.

I have no doubt next season the 49ers will be much better and back in the race to the Super Bowl. 49ers will have over $50 mil in cap space, good amount of draft picks on top of all that an easier schedule due to coming in last place (nah I don't know that lol). But IMO, Brock Purdy will be fine and so will his contract negotiations, which IMO is being blown way outta proportion.

It's not about blaming, it's recognizing deficiencies in his game. It's about the stuff he was elite at (processing and anticipation) not being up to his standards this yr.

not disagreeing that the state of the team this yr didn't play a big part in Brock's play.

We will see what they do. Hopefully they keep drafting like they did and invest in the trenches.

Well I heard a deal can take place once the clock hits 0:00 in the AZ game in Week 18 right?

Originally posted by Strwy2Hevn:

Originally posted by ninerfaninnorcal:
Do with Brock what we did with Ayiuk. Find out if other teams are even interested and for how much. Bring in Cousins or Darnold as a backup plan if he holds out.

It's time we show Brock what a hardball actually is.

He actually thinks Darnold will come here as backup. This a joke?